On this page
A rule filing is a filing that adds, changes or withdraws the manual rules that decide how an insurer's rates apply to a policy. Rules cover eligibility, classification, territory definitions, tier placement, how discounts and surcharges are applied, minimum premiums, fees, and how premium is calculated step by step. A rule filing can leave every rate number unchanged and still move premium, which is why many states review it with the same care as a rate filing.
What a rule filing covers
The NAIC's model rating law treats manuals, rating schedules, rating plans and every other rating rule as part of the rate material an insurer files. The NAIC Product Filing Review Handbook adds that each state decides what must be filed, which may include rates, rating rules, policy forms and underwriting rules, and that this can vary by product or filer.
In a property and casualty rating manual, rule changes usually fall into a few groups:
- Eligibility and classification. Which risks qualify for the program, how they are classed and what moves a risk from one class to another.
- Territory definitions. Which ZIP codes, counties or other geographic units map to which rating territory.
- Tiers and underwriting criteria. How a risk is placed in a rating tier, where the state treats those criteria as rating rules.
- Discounts and surcharges. Who qualifies, how they are verified, how they combine and in what order they apply.
- Premium mechanics. The rating algorithm, rounding, minimum premiums, installment and other fees, and cancellation and short-rate rules.
How a rule filing differs from rate and form filings
A rate filing changes prices: base rates, factors, relativities and loss cost multipliers. A form filing changes the contract language. A rule filing changes the instructions that connect the two. The difference matters because each filing type carries its own support expectations and, in many states, its own review path. Rate, rule and form filings compares the three and covers combination filings.
The lines blur in practice. A new territory definition is a rule change that usually comes with new territory relativities, which are rate changes. A new endorsement with a premium charge needs a form, a rate and a rule that says when the charge applies. Advisory organizations file rules for their members alongside loss costs, and the NAIC handbook notes that those rules can contain classification factors, increased limits factors and experience rating plans that significantly affect final premiums. It also notes that insurers often have to write their own manual rules where the advisory organization does not set one, such as minimum premiums. See Advisory organizations and loss costs.
Common examples
| Change | Why it is a rule filing | What reviewers look for |
|---|---|---|
| Tightening eligibility for a claims-free discount | Changes who receives an existing discount | Number of policyholders who lose it and the premium effect |
| Redrawing territory boundaries | Moves risks between existing territories | Policyholder impact by territory and support for the new mapping |
| Adding a rating tier | Adds a new placement rule and a new factor | Clear, objective tier criteria and support for the tier factor |
| Changing the order in which discounts apply | Changes the premium calculation without new factors | A worked example and the resulting premium change |
| Adding or changing an installment fee | Adds a charge outside the base premium | Whether the state allows the fee and how it is justified |
| Revising the schedule rating plan | Changes the criteria or range of credits and debits | Objective criteria within the state's allowed range |
How states treat rule filings
States handle rule filings differently, so read the governing statute and the department's filing instructions first. Three examples show the range.
Texas. Under 28 TAC § 5.9334, insurers filing rates under Insurance Code chapter 2251 must file new rates, rating manuals, rules, all other supplementary rating information and fees, or revisions to these items. Each filing needs a filing memorandum that explains its purpose, states the overall impact and briefly describes each change to the rates, rating manuals and rules. Filings that change relativities, including relativities implied by discounts, surcharges or tiers, need a relativity analysis together with the related territory codes, classification systems or rules. Rate indications are not required for filings that contain only supplementary rating information changes with no overall rate impact. For owner-occupied homeowners and personal auto, the rule also calls for policyholder impact information when the spread between the minimum and maximum policyholder impact is greater than 5%.
Rhode Island. The Department of Business Regulation's filing requirements say rule filings require a filing fee and a completed Rate/Rule Schedule in SERFF. Revisions to existing rules need a side-by-side comparison, with additions underlined or highlighted and deletions struck through, plus an explanation of the impact on coverage and on rate. The department does not treat changes to class definitions, territory definitions or rating rules as flex rate filings unless the insurer is adopting a rating plan already approved for other licensed carriers or advisory organizations. Underwriting guidelines are not filed, but an insurer that rates business through different tiers must have guidelines that clearly set out which risks are acceptable for each tier. The same document allows no policy fees other than those for installments, late payments and invalid or rejected payments, and requires schedule rating criteria to be filed.
New Hampshire. Ins 5001.04 requires a filing that modifies an existing rate to include a side-by-side comparison clearly showing the changes, additions or deletions to the rating manual, placed on the SERFF Rate/Rule Schedule with the final copy of the manual. When forms, rate filings and rate or form rules are filed separately, they must be cross-referenced by SERFF tracking number.
The state pages under /states link to each department's official rate and rule sources by line of business.
What goes in a rule filing
Building a rule filing
Rule pages
The new or revised manual pages, identified the same way the manual identifies its pages.
Comparison
A side-by-side or mark-up showing every addition and deletion against the current approved manual.
Explanatory memorandum
What changed, why, and the effect on coverage, eligibility and premium.
Actuarial support
Premium impact, policyholder distribution and relativity support when the rule moves premium.
Schedules and cross-references
Rule pages on the Rate/Rule Schedule and tracking numbers for related rate or form filings.
- Rule pages. File the full manual pages that change, not excerpts, so the reviewer sees each rule in context. New York's SERFF guidelines, for example, require the Rate/Rule Schedule for rate and rating rule filings and say filings with attachments on the wrong schedule will be rejected.
- A comparison. Show the prior approved wording and the new wording together. A rule that looks administrative in isolation often reads differently next to what it replaces.
- An explanatory memorandum. State the reason for the change, who it affects, and whether it broadens or restricts eligibility or coverage.
- Actuarial support when premium moves. Show the overall premium effect, the distribution of policyholder changes and support for any new or changed relativity. When the rule truly has no premium effect, say so and explain why. Actuarial memorandum and Rate filing exhibits cover the exhibits involved.
- Consistency with forms and rates. A rule that applies a charge for an endorsement should name the endorsement by number and edition, and the rate pages should carry the charge. See Form filings.
Typical objections to rule filings
- No premium impact shown. The filing calls a change administrative, but it moves risks between classes, tiers or territories.
- Subjective criteria. Eligibility, tier or schedule rating criteria that leave too much to the underwriter. The NAIC handbook says the underwriting rules for each tier should be mutually exclusive, clear and objective, and the placement process should be auditable.
- Unfair discrimination questions. A new rule treats similar risks differently without data showing a difference in expected losses or expenses.
- Missing comparison. No side-by-side or mark-up, or a comparison that leaves out changes.
- Conflicts across the program. A rule references a form edition or rate page that is not on file, or contradicts another rule in the manual.
- Charges the state does not allow. Fees or surcharges outside what the state permits, or schedule rating ranges beyond the state's limit.
Objections arrive and are answered the same way as on any other filing. See SERFF objections for how responses work and State filing requirements and checklists for assembling a state's full requirement list before the filing goes in. Other carriers' public filings show how departments handled similar rule changes. See SERFF filing search.
Sources
- NAIC, Product Filing Review Handbook (2024)
- NAIC, Property and Casualty Model Rating Law (Prior Approval Version), GL-1780
- 28 Tex. Admin. Code § 5.9334, Requirements for Rate and Rule Filing Submissions (Cornell LII)
- Rhode Island Department of Business Regulation, Property & Casualty Rate, Rule & Policy Form Filing Requirements and Regulatory Compliance
- New Hampshire Code of Administrative Rules, Ins 5000: Standards and Procedures for the Filing of Property and Casualty Insurance Forms and Rates
- New York DFS, General SERFF Guidelines for Rate, Form, Territory, Classification and Rule Filings
General information about regulatory practice, not legal or actuarial advice. Requirements differ by state, line and filing; check the current rules with the department of insurance before you file.