Skip to content

Learn / Rate filings

Insurance rate filings: how they work, end to end

Updated · 15 min read

On this page

An insurance rate filing is the submission an insurer makes to a state insurance department to establish or change the prices it charges for a line of business. It contains the rate and rule pages the company wants to use and the actuarial support showing those rates are not excessive, inadequate or unfairly discriminatory. Depending on the state's rating law, the department approves the rates before use, accepts them on filing or reviews them afterward. Most property and casualty rate filings are submitted through SERFF, the NAIC's filing system, one state at a time.

This page follows a rate filing from start to finish and links to the library's deeper page on each step. It is written for filing analysts, pricing actuaries and compliance staff who need the whole sequence in one place.

What a rate filing is, and what it is not

States regulate three things an insurer files: rates (the prices), rules (how the prices apply) and forms (the contract language). A rate filing changes base rates, rating factors, minimum premiums or loss cost multipliers. A rule filing changes eligibility, classification, territory, discount or fee rules, and can move premium even when no rate number changes. A form filing changes policy forms and endorsements. A change that touches more than one, such as a new endorsement with a premium charge, is usually a combination filing or a set of linked filings. Rate, rule and form filings maps common changes to the filing type each needs, and Rule filings covers what a rule change requires on its own.

Form filings run alongside many rate changes, and they are judged on different grounds: whether required provisions are present, prohibited provisions absent and the language readable. The NAIC Product Filing Review Handbook notes that form and rate reviewers may need to coordinate so related changes take effect consistently. Form filings: what regulators check covers that review.

The vocabulary is dense and state usage varies. The insurance filing glossary defines terms such as deemer, waiting period, loss adjustment expense and increased limits factor as they are used in filings.

Who regulates rates, and why it is the states

Insurance in the United States is regulated mainly by the states. The McCarran-Ferguson Act of 1945 left regulation and taxation with them, and the NAIC model rating laws that followed are the basis of most state rating laws today. The NAIC coordinates regulators and runs SERFF, but it is not itself a regulator of insurers. A company writing in 40 states answers to 40 departments, each applying its own code. How insurance is regulated in the US explains the structure and where federal law reaches in.

Whether a rate filing is needed at all depends on the insurer's status and the business. An admitted insurer holds the state's license and is subject to its rate and form filing laws. Surplus lines rates and forms are generally not filed, and under federal law only the insured's home state regulates a surplus lines placement. Admitted and non-admitted insurers covers when each applies.

Commercial business has its own exceptions. Many states relax rate and form filing for large, sophisticated buyers or for whole lines, under size and sophistication criteria set in each state's law. An exemption from filing is not an exemption from regulation, since disclosure and record requirements usually remain. Commercial lines filing exemptions shows how to confirm one applies.

Two more structures change who files and how. Residual market mechanisms such as FAIR plans and auto assigned risk plans usually file their own rates, often under prior approval, and their deficits can lead to assessments on voluntary insurers. Residual markets explains why filers watch them. For life, annuity, disability income and long-term care products, the Interstate Insurance Product Regulation Commission reviews certain filings once against uniform standards for its member states. Property and casualty rates are outside its scope and are filed with each state. The Interstate Compact covers when it suits a filer.

The test every rate must pass

Almost every state property and casualty rating law says rates shall not be excessive, inadequate or unfairly discriminatory. The NAIC prior approval model states its purpose in those words. Excessive means too high for the coverage provided. Inadequate means too low to sustain the costs the rate is meant to cover. Unfairly discriminatory means price differences that do not reflect differences in expected losses and expenses, and some characteristics are barred as rating factors outright.

The standard applies to both the overall rate level and the structure of the rating plan, so a filing has to support the indication and each factor and class that changes. The Casualty Actuarial Society's ratemaking principles describe a rate as an estimate of expected future costs, which is the frame most reviewers apply. Rate standards goes through what each standard means in practice and how regulators test it.

Rating laws: prior approval, file and use, use and file

The state's rating system decides when the department applies the standard, not whether it applies. The NAIC handbook groups state laws into a few systems, and each state defines its own version:

SystemWhen rates can be usedWhat it means for the filer
Prior approvalAfter the department approves, explicitly or through a deemerObjections directly control the effective date
File and useOnce filed, or after a short specified periodThe department can disapprove later, usually prospectively
Use and fileFirst, with a filing due within a set periodReview happens after the rates are in the market
No fileWithout filingSupporting data must still be kept and produced on request
Flex ratingDepends on the size of the changeChanges beyond a set band need prior approval

The NAIC handbook notes that every state has a property and casualty rating law except Illinois. The system often depends on the line as well as the state, with personal auto and homeowners more often under prior approval than commercial lines.

Deemer provisions deserve care. The NAIC prior approval model treats a filing as meeting the law unless disapproved within a waiting period, and its drafting note records that state waiting periods ranged from 15 to 90 days when the model was published. Under the model, the clock starts only when the filing's supporting information is furnished, so an incomplete filing can lose its place. Prior approval, file-and-use and use-and-file explains each system, how deemers work and the order in which to read primary sources for one state and line.

Where the rate comes from: own experience or advisory loss costs

Many insurers do not build every rate from their own data. In workers' compensation, many commercial lines and some personal lines, an advisory organization files prospective loss costs, the portion of the rate that covers expected losses. Each insurer then adds its own expense and profit provisions through a loss cost multiplier, so the rate equals the prospective loss cost times the multiplier. The insurer files that multiplier and any deviations, such as changed classes or a percentage deviation from the advisory level, with each state.

This choice shapes the filing. A company filing its own rates needs a full actuarial memorandum and indication. A company adopting loss costs files a reference to the advisory filing, its multiplier calculation and support for each deviation. Advisory organizations, loss costs and loss cost multipliers covers both paths and what reviewers look for.

Planning a rate change

A rate change is in force only when the filing has cleared review, the rating systems charge the new rates and every required policyholder notice has gone out. The slowest of these sets the calendar, so planning works backward from the renewal effective date.

A rate filing from indication to effective date

  1. Indication

    Estimate the change needed from experience, loss development, trend and expense provisions.

  2. Selection and approval

    Choose the overall change and its distribution, and clear internal sign-offs.

  3. Build each state's filing

    Assemble rate and rule pages, memoranda, exhibits and state forms to each state's requirements.

  4. Submit in SERFF

    Code the filing, complete the schedules and pay any fees, one filing per state.

  5. Review and objections

    The reviewer checks completeness, then substance, and asks questions in objection letters.

  6. Disposition and implementation

    Implement the final approved pages and send required notices before the effective dates.

Durations depend on the state, the line, the rating law and the insurer's own processes.

Policyholder notice often sets the outer limit. Florida, for example, requires at least 45 days' advance written notice of nonrenewal or of the renewal premium for many property, casualty and workers' compensation policies, with exceptions and longer periods for some residential property. A multistate change is a separate filing in each state with its own clock, and an amendment in one does not carry over to the others. Planning a rate change walks through sequencing across states, new business and renewal dates, and implementation.

Building the filing

Requirements first

A filing's requirements are the full list of what the state expects: documents, exhibits, certifications, schedule entries, fees and content standards for that state, line and filing type. No single document holds that list. It is assembled from statutes, regulations, bulletins, the state's SERFF General Instructions and Filing Rules, and the NAIC Uniform Review Standards Checklists. The NAIC handbook ties delays to requirements a filer did not identify during product development, and says a complete initial submission is handled faster because less time goes to correspondence.

Build the checklist per filing, not per state, and record a source and the date checked for each row. New York's published SERFF guidelines show why. They say the appropriate Review Standards Checklist is mandatory for every SERFF filing, and that filings with forms or rates on the wrong schedule will be rejected. State filing requirements and checklists shows how to build and maintain one. The state coverage pages summarize each jurisdiction's regulator, filing system and official sources by line.

The package

A rate filing is a package, not a single document. Most contain transmittal and rate summary data, rate and rule manual pages (clean and with comparison pages), an explanatory memorandum, the actuarial memorandum and exhibits, and any state forms or certifications. States collect standard summary figures for each rate filing. New Mexico's rule is a representative list: whether the filing is an increase, decrease or rate neutral, the overall indicated change, the overall rate impact, the written premium change, the number of policyholders affected, the maximum and minimum percentage changes, and the date and size of the last revision. Those figures have to match the memorandum and exhibits exactly. What goes in a rate filing lists the standard components and the checks to run before submitting.

The actuarial memorandum

The memorandum explains how the proposed rates were developed: the data, the adjustments, the provisions for expenses and profit, the indication, and the selection with reasons for any difference from the indication. The exhibits carry the numbers, and the memorandum is the argument connecting them. A useful test is whether a regulator's actuary could reproduce the path from data to selected rates from the memorandum alone. The actuarial memorandum covers its typical structure, the actuarial standards of practice it engages and the weaknesses that draw objections.

Loss development

Recent accident years are still open, so their reported losses understate what the claims will cost. Loss development adjusts them to an estimated ultimate value using the pattern older years followed: compile a triangle, calculate age-to-age factors, average and select them, choose a tail and project. The mechanics are arithmetic, but the selections are judgment, and the tail factor touches every accident year. The NAIC handbook cautions that development is not trend. Development moves one accident year to ultimate, and trend moves ultimate losses from one period to the next. Loss development: triangles, factors and tail selection shows what a development exhibit should let a reader test.

Filing in SERFF

SERFF, the System for Electronic Rates & Forms Filing, is the NAIC application insurers and filing agents use to submit rate, rule and form filings, and that state reviewers use to review and close them. A SERFF filing is one submission to one state. The same product filed in 30 states is 30 filings, each with its own tracking number, reviewer, correspondence and outcome. The NAIC is replacing the legacy application, and states move to the modernized platform on a published schedule, so screens and workflow can change for a given state. What is SERFF? covers the filing tabs, schedules and public access.

Several mechanics decide whether a filing reaches the right reviewer intact:

  • TOI and sub-TOI codes. Every filing carries one type of insurance code and one sub-type from the NAIC Product Coding Matrix, such as 04.0 Homeowners with a sub-TOI under it, or 04.0000 when a filing spans several homeowners sub-TOIs. The code, with the filing type, selects the state's requirements for that combination. Use the matrix in effect on the filing date. See SERFF type of insurance codes.
  • Fees. The NAIC's billing page says SERFF has no licensing fee but charges a per-filing transaction fee. State filing fees are separate, set by each state and often paid through SERFF by electronic funds transfer. The NAIC's state participation page shows each state's fee and EFT notes. See SERFF filing fees.
  • Tracking numbers. SERFF assigns a tracking number when the filing is created. The SERFF Glossary describes a four-character instance identifier joined to a system-generated string. A filing can also carry separate state and company tracking numbers. See SERFF tracking numbers explained.
  • Confidentiality. In most states a filing is a public record. A filer can flag items as confidential in SERFF, but SERFF treats the flag as a request that each state reviews under its own law, often with an affidavit or justification. See Confidentiality and trade secrets in filings.

Teams that work with many filings often ask about automation. SERFF offers integration interfaces for states and filers under legal agreements with the NAIC, and the modernized platform adds new APIs. For public filings, the NAIC's February 2026 steering committee summary says there are presently no services or bulk downloads for SERFF Filing Access data. Does SERFF have an API? sets out the options, and Automating SERFF filing prep covers what can be automated around a filing and what stays with people.

Review and objections

Filings are read by people: rate analysts and actuaries applying the state's law, its bulletins and their experience of what a complete filing looks like. The NAIC handbook describes the sequence. At intake, a complete filing is assigned to a reviewer, and an incomplete one may be rejected or met with a request for more information. The reviewer then checks completeness and compliance and sends deficiencies to the filer in writing. Departments rarely publish standard review times, and bulletins and circular letters often carry requirements as binding in practice as the statute. Inside a state insurance department covers how departments are organized and how to work with reviewers.

Objections are the normal way questions arrive, not a sign the filing will fail. In SERFF, a state's objections come as an Objection Letter on the filing's Correspondence tab, often with a response date. The filer revises the schedules and answers in a Response Letter. SERFF's help pages say there can only be one Response Letter for each Objection Letter, so the response has to address every objection, even where nothing changes. Deadlines are set by the state and vary by letter. Common themes include selections without support, figures that do not tie across the package, missing state forms and rating factors without justification. SERFF objections covers the response mechanics, common themes and how to write a response that closes the question.

Two ways a review can run

Most filings

Paper review

  • Exchange between filer and reviewer in SERFF
  • Questions arrive as objection letters
  • Closed with a disposition on the documents

Some states and lines

Formal hearing

  • Triggered by statute, the regulator, the public or the filer
  • Formal record, witnesses and discovery
  • More time and cost, and outside parties may take part
Hearing triggers vary by state, line and rating system.

A few filings go further. In some states and lines the rating law allows a formal hearing, called by the regulator, requested by the public or requested by the insurer after an adverse order, and some states allow consumer intervenors to take part. The NAIC prior approval model, for example, lets an insurer request a hearing on a disapproval. Rate hearings, intervenors and public input explains when this happens and how to prepare a filing that could face cross-examination.

After approval

The disposition records what the state allowed: approval as filed, approval with modifications, partial withdrawal, disapproval or rejection, in the state's own vocabulary. The final approved rate pages, not the original submission, are what the company may use, so implementation in rating, policy and billing systems should start from them. Keep the SERFF, state and company tracking numbers together in the filing log, since later market conduct work and the next filing will refer back to this one. An insurer charging something other than its filed rates is a market conduct problem as well as a filing problem.

Once closed, many filings become public. Many rating laws open a filing and its supporting information to public inspection, either when it is filed or when it takes effect, and most states publish property and casualty filings through SERFF Filing Access. Material a state accepts as a trade secret is withheld, and filings older than a state's online coverage can usually be obtained by records request. Are insurance rate filings public? covers where to look and what stays out of view.

Public filings close the loop. Recent approved filings for the same state and line show what a department accepted, how other carriers supported their indications and, where correspondence is public, what reviewers asked. A competitor's filing shows what was accepted at a point in time, not what will be accepted next. Check the disposition and the date before treating it as precedent. SERFF filing search describes how to search other carriers' public filings across states.

A working checklist for any rate filing

  • Confirm the insurer's status, the line and any exemption, then the rating law and deemer rules for each state, from the statute and regulations.
  • Decide whether the rate comes from company experience, adopted loss costs or both, and what that means for the exhibits.
  • Build the requirements checklist per filing from the state's SERFF instructions, checklists, statutes and current bulletins, with a source and date for each row.
  • Make the rate summary, explanatory memorandum, actuarial memorandum and exhibits agree to the decimal.
  • Choose the TOI, sub-TOI and filing type from the current matrix and the state's accepted filing types, and budget transaction and state fees per filing.
  • Prepare confidentiality requests and public versions before submission, not after.
  • Read recent public filings and their correspondence for the same state and line to anticipate the first objection letter.
  • Plan notice and implementation backward from the renewal effective date, and implement only the final approved pages.

Sources

  1. NAIC, Product Filing Review Handbook (2024)
  2. NAIC, Property and Casualty Model Rating Law (Prior Approval Version), GL-1780
  3. NAIC, Uniform Property & Casualty Product Coding Matrix (effective January 1, 2026)
  4. NAIC, System for Electronic Rates & Forms Filing (SERFF)
  5. NAIC, SERFF state participation
  6. NAIC, SERFF Billing
  7. NAIC, SERFF modernization
  8. NAIC, SERFF Product Steering Committee meeting summary (February 25, 2026)
  9. SERFF, SERFF Glossary
  10. SERFF Help, Confidentiality Requests
  11. SERFF Help, Responses & Amendments FAQ
  12. New York DFS, General SERFF Guidelines for Rate, Form, Territory, Classification and Rule Filings
  13. New Mexico Administrative Code 13.8.2: Rate Filings by Insurers and Rate Service Organizations
  14. Florida Statutes § 627.4133, Notice of cancellation, nonrenewal, or renewal premium
  15. 15 U.S.C. § 8202, Regulation of nonadmitted insurance by insured's home State
  16. Interstate Insurance Product Regulation Commission, About
  17. Casualty Actuarial Society, Statement of Principles Regarding Property and Casualty Insurance Ratemaking
  18. Friedland, Estimating Unpaid Claims Using Basic Techniques (CAS study note)

General information about regulatory practice, not legal or actuarial advice. Requirements differ by state, line and filing; check the current rules with the department of insurance before you file.